Associated Press All-American
| Name | Class | Position | Award Level | Season Awarded |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zack Chevalier | Class: JR | Position: QB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2024 |
| Isaac Pingel | Class: SR | Position: LB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2024 |
| Drew Sellon | Class: JR | Position: WR | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2024 |
| Dijion Walls | Class: SR | Position: DB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2024 |
| Aidan Queen | Class: SR | Position: OL | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2024 |
| Lonell Boyd Jr. | Class: SR | Position: DB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2023 |
| Riley Lindberg | Class: SR | Position: OL | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2023 |
| Isaac Pingel | Class: SR | Position: DB | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2023 |
| Tyler Anderson | Class: SR | Position: OL | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2022 |
| Ryan Cole | Class: SO | Position: RB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2022 |
| Joe Dolincheck | Class: SR | Position: QB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2022 |
| Austin Johnson | Class: SR | Position: WR | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2022 |
| Zach Norton | Class: JR | Position: WR | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2022 |
| Weston Schultz | Class: SR | Position: DL | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2022 |
| Dijion Walls | Class: JR | Position: DB | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2022 |
| Joe Dolincheck | Class: SR | Position: QB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2021 |
| Jason Hahlbeck | Class: SR | Position: OL | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2021 |
| Anthony Sims | Class: SR | Position: RB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2021 |
| Tyler Wingert | Class: SR | Position: LB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2021 |
| Chase Carter | Class: JR | Position: K | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2021 |
| Reid Jurgensmeier | Class: SR | Position: WR | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2021 |
| Weston Schultz | Class: SR | Position: DL | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2021 |
| AP Ponder | Class: JR | Position: RB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2019 |
| Garrett Temme | Class: SR | Position: OL | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2019 |
| Joe Dolincheck | Class: SO | Position: QB | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2019 |
| Reid Jurgensmeier | Class: JR | Position: WR | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2019 |
| Klayton Nordeen | Class: SR | Position: DB | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2019 |
| Connor Niles | Class: SR | Position: WR | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2018 |
| Trent Solsma | Class: SR | Position: QB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2018 |
| Xavier Spann | Class: SR | Position: DB | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2018 |
| Spencer Wyant | Class: SR | Position: P | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2018 |
| Trae Bradburn | Class: | Position: OL | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2017 |
| Bubba Jenkins | Class: | Position: RB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2017 |
| Caden McDonald | Class: | Position: LB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2017 |
| Connor Niles | Class: JR | Position: WR | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 2017 |
| Jason Lupkes | Class: | Position: DL | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 2017 |
| Brandon Wegher | Class: JR | Position: RB | Award Level: Third Team | Season Awarded: 2014 |
| Dean Jones | Class: | Position: DL | Award Level: Third Team | Season Awarded: 1992 |
| Dave Bigler | Class: | Position: RB | Award Level: Second Team | Season Awarded: 1971 |
| Truman O'Doherty | Class: | Position: OL | Award Level: | Season Awarded: 1956 |
| Dwaine Miller | Class: | Position: | Award Level: Third Team | Season Awarded: 1954 |
| Connie Callahan | Class: | Position: QB | Award Level: First Team | Season Awarded: 1949 |
| Steve Smilonich | Class: | Position: OL | Award Level: | Season Awarded: 1940 |