NAIA All-American
| Name | Class | Season |
|---|---|---|
| JR Albers | Class: JR | Season: 2021-22 |
| James Camp | Class: SR | Season: 2021-22 |
| Joe Ciriaco | Class: SO | Season: 2021-22 |
| Willy Pinnow | Class: JR | Season: 2021-22 |
| Caleb Thomson | Class: JR | Season: 2021-22 |
| JR Albers | Class: SO | Season: 2020-21 |
| James Camp | Class: JR | Season: 2020-21 |
| Joe Ciriaco | Class: FR | Season: 2020-21 |
| Ron DeFauw | Class: JR | Season: 2020-21 |
| Kyle Gundersen | Class: JR | Season: 2020-21 |
| Willy Pinnow | Class: FR | Season: 2020-21 |
| James Spicer | Class: JR | Season: 2020-21 |
| Caleb Thomson | Class: SO | Season: 2020-21 |