NCAA DII All-American
| Name | Year | Position | Season Awarded |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year: | Position: QB | Season Awarded: 1954 | |
| Year: | Position: HB | Season Awarded: 1949 | |
| Year: | Position: RB | Season Awarded: 1971 | |
| Year: | Position: DL | Season Awarded: 1992 | |
| Year: | Position: OT | Season Awarded: 1965 | |
| Year: | Position: | Season Awarded: 1917 | |
| Year: | Position: OL | Season Awarded: 1990 | |
| Year: | Position: K | Season Awarded: 1991 | |
| Year: | Position: SE | Season Awarded: 1964 | |
| Year: | Position: DB | Season Awarded: 1999 | |
| Year: | Position: WR | Season Awarded: 1998 | |
| Year: | Position: WR | Season Awarded: 1999 | |
| Year: | Position: OG | Season Awarded: 1940 | |
| Year: | Position: C | Season Awarded: 1956 |